Last Updated: April 8, 2013 at 10:12 AM
Davis v. Perry
Case Information
Date Filed: September 22, 2011
State: Texas
Issues: Redistricting, Vote Dillution
Current Court: United States Court for the Western District of Texas (Case 5:11-cv-00788)
Issue:
Whether Texas' State Senate Redistricting Plan violates the Voting Rights Act.
Status:
District Court adopted interim redistricting plan on 11/26/11. U.S. Supreme Court stayed District Court order pending oral argument scheduled 1/9/12. Supreme Court opinion filed 1/20/12. District Court Order Entering a Redistricting Plan 3/1/12. Court Order Adopting interim plan for 2012 election entered 9/7/12.
See also Davis v. Perry and Perez v. Texas
Supreme Court Documents
- Appellant's Jurisdictional Statement
(filed 10/19/12) - Mexican-American Legislative Caucus' Motion to Affirm
(filed 12/6/12) - United States' Motion to Affirm in Part
(filed 12/7/12) - Davis' Motion to Affirm
(filed 12/7/12) - Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force's Motion to Affirm
(filed 12/7/12) - Appellant's Reply Brief
(filed 12/13/12)
District Court Documents
- Complaint
(filed 7/19/11) - Application for Three-Judge Court
(filed 7/20/11) - Notice and Memo in Support of Application
(filed 7/20/11) - Order Granting Application for Three-Judge Court
(filed 7/21/11) - Motion by Davis et al to Intervene
(filed 7/21/11) - Response of AG Holder
(filed 7/27/11) - Texas' Response in Opposition to Intervention
(filed 8/3/11) - Davis et al Reply in Support of Intervention
(filed 8/8/11) - Texas' Motion to Expedite
(filed 8/11/11) - Order Granting Motion to Intervene
(filed 8/16/11) - Answer of Davis et al
(filed 8/17/11) - MALC's Motion to Intervene
(filed 8/17/11) - TLRTF's Motion to Intervene
(filed 8/17/11) - MALC Response
(filed 8/21/11) - TLBC Motion to Intervene
(filed 8/22/11) - TLRTF Motion to Intervene as Defendant
(filed 8/22/11) - Attorney General's Combined Response to Motion to Intervene
(filed 8/24/11) - Plaintiff's Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Intervention
(filed 8/26/11) - Proposed Intervenors' Reply in Support of Motion to Intervene as Defendants
(filed 9/02/11) - Joint Reply of the Texas Black Caucus and MALc to Plaintiff's Opposition to Intervention
(filed 9/05/11) - Motion for Leave to Intervene as Defendants
(filed 9/06/11) - Order Granting Motion to Intervene
(filed 9/08/11) - Proposed Answer of Defendant-Intervenor MALC
(filed 9/08/11) - Answer of Defendant-Intervenors
(filed 9/08/11) - Proposed Answer of Defendant-Intervenor Texas Legislative Black Caucus
(filed 9/08/11) - Answer of Defendant-Intervenor Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force to Plaintiff's Complaint for Declaratory Judgment
(filed 9/08/11) - Answer of Proposed Defendendant-Intervenors
(filed 9/08/11) - Motion by League of United Latin American Citizens to Intervene as Defendant
(filed 9/12/11) - Plaintiff State of Texas of Texas' Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 9/14/11) - Answer of Defendant-Intervenors
(filed 9/15/11) - Answer of Defendant Holder
(filed 9/19/11) - Attorney General's Response to Motion to Intervene
(filed 9/21/11) - Intervenor's Legal Statement on How Destruction of Senate district 10 Violates Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act
(filed 9/23/11) - US' Identification of Issues
(filed 9/23/11) - Order Granting Motion to Intervene
(filed 9/29/11) - US' Identification of Elections Considered
(filed 10/03/11) - Order Granting Motion to Intervene
(filed 10/07/11) - Expert Report of John Alford
(filed 10/14/11) - Defendant-Intervenor Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - MALC and LULAC's Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - Davis' Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - Gonzales' Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - Texas Latino Redistrciting Task Force's Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - Response of Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - TLBC, NAACP, and LULAC's Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/25/11) - Texas' Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 10/31/11) - Texas' Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 11/01/11) - Letter Regarding Speed of Decision
(filed 11/04/11) - Order Denying Motion for Summary Judgment
(filed 11/08/11) - Memorandum Opinion
(filed 12/22/11) - TLRTF Advisory Regarding Plaintiff's Response to Requests for Production
(filed 12/28/11) - Brief of U.S. Regarding Plaintiff's Assertion of Various Privileges
(filed 12/28/11) - Davis' Memorandum Regarding Plaintiff's Objections to Discovery Based on Privilege
(filed 12/28/11) - Plaintiff's Brief Regarding Applicability of Various Privileges
(12/28/11) - Joint Notice of Trial Witnesses
(filed 12/28/11) - Reply of Davis Intervenors to Plaintiff's Memorandum on Privilege
(filed 12/30/11) - Reply of U.S. to Plaintiff's Memorandum on Privilege
(filed 12/30/11) - Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' Memoranda on Privilege
(filed 12/30/11) - Memorandum Opinion on Privilege Claims
(filed 1/02/12) - Order on Various Complaints
(filed 1/02/12) - Trial Scheduling Order
(filed 1/04/12) - Motion to Exclude Testimony of Defendant's Experts
(filed 1/04/12) - Plaintiff's Brief on Privilege
(filed 1/05/12) - Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Supplemental Brief Regarding Privilege
(filed 1/05/12) - Texas' Pre-filed Testimony
(filed 1/10/12) - NAACP's Pre-filed Testimony
(filed 1/10/12) - Joint Trial Brief of Davis, NAACP, LULAC, and Texas Legislative Black Caucus
(filed 1/13/12) - Trial Brief of Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force
(filed 1/13/12) - Trial Brief of Texas Legislative Black Caucus and NAACP
(filed 1/13/12) - US' Opening Trial Brief
(filed 1/13/12) - Pre-Trial Brief of NAACP
(filed 1/13/12) - Memorandum in Opposition to Motion to Exclude Testimony
(filed 1/13/12) - Gonzales and Davis' Trial Brief
(filed 1/13/12) - Joint Opposition to Motion to Exclude Testimony
(filed 1/13/12) - Reply to Defendants' Opposition to Motion to Exclude Testimony
(filed 1/15/12) - Davis' Submission of Expert Witness Reports
(filed 1/16/12) - MALC's Notice of Submission of Testimony of Dr. Kousser
(filed 1/16/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Ansolbehere
(filed 1/17/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Wendy Davis
(filed 1/17/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Kousser
(filed 1/17/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Escamilla
(filed 1/17/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Alford
(filed 1/17/12) - Filing of Dr. Murray's Expert Opinion
(filed 1/19/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Arrington
(filed 1/20/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Kousser
(filed 1/20/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Flores
(filed 1/20/12) - Submission of Expert Witness Testimony of Dr. Engstorm
(filed 1/20/12) - Gonzales' Bench Brief Regarding Use of General election Data in Coalition Districts
(filed 1/23/12) - US Closing Argument
(filed 2/01/12) - Closing Argument of Hebert
(filed 2/01/12) - Closing Argument of MALC
(filed 2/01/12) - Closing Argument of Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force
(filed 2/01/12) - State of Texas Closing Argument
(filed 2/01/12) - Gonzales Closing Argument
(filed 2/01/12) - Joint Stipulation of Facts
(filed 2/02/12) - Request for Judicial Notice of Evidence
(filed 2/03/12) - NAACP Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - LULAC Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - MALC Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - Davis' Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - US' Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - State of Texas' Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force's Proposed Findings of Fact
(filed 2/03/12) - Gonzales Intervenors' Summary of Expert Testimony
(filed 2/06/12) - Davis' Summary of Expert Witness Testimony
(filed 2/06/12) - Proposed Stipulation by Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force
(filed 2/06/12) - MALC Summary of Report of Expert Dr. Kousser
(filed 2/06/12) - MALC's Post Trial Brief
(filed 2/06/12) - Summary of Expert Testimony of Dean Saenz
(filed 2/06/12) - Texas Legislative Black Caucus Post Trial Brief
(filed 2/06/12) - Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force's Summary of Expert Dr. Engstrom
(filed 2/06/12) - Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force's Summary of Expert Dr. Flores
(filed 2/06/12) - NAACP Post Trial Brief
(filed 2/06/12) - Summary of Expert Testimony of Dr. Murray
(filed 2/06/12) - Summary of Expert Testimony of Dr. Arrington
(filed 2/06/12) - State of Texas' Trial Brief
(filed 2/06/12) - Summary of Expert Testimony of Dr. Handley
(filed 2/06/12) - US's Post Trial Brief
(filed 2/06/12) - Davis and LULAC's Post Trial Brief
(filed 2/06/12) - Post Trial Brief Gonzales
(filed 2/07/12) - Post Trial Brief of Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force
(filed 2/07/12) - Joint Advisory of Defendant-Intervenors
(filed 2/22/12) - Response of Certain Defendants to Advisory of Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force
(filed 3/01/12) - Texas' Advisory Regarding 2012 Election Schedule
(filed 3/01/12) - State of Texas' Memorandum on District 25
(filed 3/13/12) - Defendant's Memorandum on District 25
(filed 3/13/12) - NAACP's Memorandum on District 25
(filed 3/13/12) - Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force's Memorandum on District 25
(filed 3/13/12) - Response to Certain Defendants to Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force's Brief Regarding Congressional District 25
(filed 3/16/12) - Response of Texas Latino Redistricting Task Force to Brief Regarding District 25
(filed 4/02/12) - Motion for Judicial Notice of 2012 Primary Results
(filed 7/05/12) - Defendant-Intervenors' Response to Motion for Judicial Notice
(filed 7/19/12) - Reply Memorandum of Defendant-Intervenors' in Support of Motion for Judicial Notice of Results from 2012 Primary
(filed 7/25/12) - Order on Motions to Take Judicial Notice
(filed 8/28/12) - Order Denying Motion to Intervene
(filed 8/28/12) - Opinion
(filed 8/28/12) - Final Judgment
(filed 8/28/12) - Notice of Appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States
(filed 8/31/12) - Unopposed Motion to Postpone and Hold in Abeyance Filings of Motions for Attorney's Fees
(filed 9/10/12) - Notice of Receipt of Appeal
(filed 10/23/12)


Commentary
FAQ on social welfare organizations
Donald B. Tobin
The Frank E. and Virginia H. Bazler Designated Professor in Business Law and a senior fellow at Election Law @ Moritz explains the nuances of social welfare organizations and federal regulations related to them.
more commentary...